It has to do with how can I control this bubble right around me thats imploding? The day after Pappu asked Sheridan the question, the writer got a flurry of texts from Paramount. The Texans in 1883 first antagonise the immigrants, but then make the compassionate choice to help them out. Yellowstone's success could be due to its ability to showcase elements of American life that some might not be familiar with while exploring compelling conflicts. These characters are sometimes unequal to these duties and fail to meet them, but the duties themselvesand the authority they stem fromare almost never in question. I didnt see that coming. But even then, Sheridan saw his once vibrant home suffering due to an economic and literal drought in the region, a final nail in the coffin to a way of life that I thought was a constant. And at the same time, he saw the media vilifying and attacking those within his community. Indiewire basically calls this subplot in 1923 critical race theory, and theyre not wrong. But to have the conversation is healthy for both sides. Emma Stone, Natalie Portman and Amy Adams were early and clear frontrunners in this category, so while Neggas performance in Loving was lauded by critics, it was surprising to see her replace Amy Adams in the final ballot. The audience is seemingly told they should be happy these characters exist at all, or aren't played by white men. Very sociological, but amazing. Instead, "Moonlight," "Fences,""Hidden Figures' and"Lion" are the movies that are bringing diversity to the Oscar race. Sheridan told Pappu that he didnt remember the quote (I dont recall that) and blamed it on being at Cannes (which he wasnt) and being extremely exhausted from the demands of all-day press junkets. It is this burden that characters in the Yellowstone universeat least the ones audiences root fordo not have to shoulder, precisely because they are immersed in meaningful communities that provide ready-made answers to these questions. Sheridan's cousin is McLennan County Sheriff Parnell McNamara, who has been in the position for 10 years, according to KWTX. But the conservative principle of Yellowstone is withdrawal. This differentiates his work from the likes of e.g. Taylor Sheridan maintains an intriguing level of mystery that feels unheard of in Hollywood, especially since he oversees a not-insignificant media empire and appears in many of the things he creates. Unless, you know, he decides to show up anyway and demand an explanation for why he wasn't nominated. When you tune into that show and see that extreme apathy toward social progress and the institutions that have made it possible, then you have on some level accepted the frame that social institutions are failing, that they are going to continue to fail and that the logical response is not to shore up those institutions. Privacy Policy and The farm is facing foreclosure because they brothers took out a predatory loan to pay for hospice care for their mother. They threatened to pull a visit to the Yellowstone set, but he ultimately made the trip anyway. Oh, Loosey! But Sheridan who essentially has a blank check from Paramount has the clout to get it made, and the audience to ensure that its seen. Meanwhile, the Texas rangers investigating their case are a racist cop near retirement played by Jeff Bridges and his Native American partner. . A trailer for the new season of the Taylor Sheridan-show revealed Dutton's process of being sworn in as governor, only adding more clout to the seventh-generation rancher and his dynasty, but . And rather than holding him back, his Texas outpost may well become Sheridans superpower. 4 min read Taylor Sheridan is the first to admit that the number of series he is fielding for various Paramount platforms is "excessive." "This volume of work is not. Im not saying that Sheridan himself should write the series and run it obviously, it should be written by Native Americans. Any Yellowstone meta-analysis is really asking what Americans can and should think of institutions. It seems almost impossible for people to have a dialogue and discuss. Can Anyone Predict Whos Going to Win Best Supporting Actress? Still, its impossible to tell what Sheridans views are on guns, and he wants to keep it that way. Weve got romance, breakups, emotionally loaded dumplings this episode has a little bit of everything! They were victims of abuse, victims of poverty. But its magnified because its the last chance he has to spend time with this guy, and look at how he treats it. Sheridan doesnt want to tell you how to think, but his stories are crystal clear about where he stands. He is a failed actor-turned-genius writer and director, who almost did not succeed. One woman wrote a very long DM to justify herself and explain to me that she was a true progressive. The creators, Taylor Sheridan and John Linson, have crossbred a throwback . Soon after moving back to his native Texas, Sheridanclinched a $150m+ deal with Paramount. Pappu also brought up comments Sheridan made in 2018 about white privilege (this time to Esquire) Help me, Mr. Harvard-fucking-Ph.D., convince the man whos losing his ranch, who cant afford his kids collegehe has no health care, he has no fucking clue what Obamacare is, hes never seen a social-security-fucking-office, his only concept of federal government is taxes. In my view, the answer to this quandary is straightforward. If Yellowstone was a liberal show aimed at liberal politics, its foundational principle would be reformation, right? He talked . cowboy). However, as much as 1923s unflinching look at anti-Indigenous violence gives us a genuinely radical critique of structural racism (to say nothing of the series deep and abiding environmentalist anti-capitalism), it is also not hard to see what right-wingers see in the show. Your Privacy Choices: Opt Out of Sale/Targeted Ads. This confirms the key points inPart 1 of this article. Mercifully there are very few Hitlers. Sheridan has opted for melodrama and heart. Yellowstone presents a counternarrative to the the gray-haired, paranoid character that we mock on social media, and more liberal media, and prestige media. Password must be at least 8 characters and contain: As part of your account, youll receive occasional updates and offers from New York, which you can opt out of anytime. By Wednesday/Thursday, we had a full script." Stallone plays a New York Mafia capo who, having served a 25-year prison sentence, gets sent to. Sign up for THR news straight to your inbox every day. And so theres a sense of independence that exists in small town Texas, in small town everywhere - small town Wyoming, small town Nevada. While John Dutton represents the white conservative man, his quest for power is portrayed in a negative light, showing the tragic consequences of greed. SIGN UP FOR OUR FREE DAILY NEWSLETTER, FIRST TAKE. But when a journalist got too close to uncovering his politics for a recent profile, he got pushback from Sheridan himself and the larger Paramount apparatus. Everyone else lives in some varying degree in between., Sheridan is also an actor, who is probable best known for his role as David Hale in Sons of Anarchy. He received aWriters Guild of America Awardnomination forBest Original Screenplayfor his previous film, 2015s Sicario.. Its amazing visually, but the politics of having that kind of diversity is very cosmetic, which is the preference of white identity politics that says, For liberals to call us racists, when we accept all people, this is the American principle of a melting pot. But the cowboy hats and horses may also obscure Sheridan's real politics. As soon as we start focusing on the similarities and not the distinctions, then we got em, hesaid. Instead,Yellowstoneis just a somewhat centrist drama in a genre that has traditionally leaned very slightly to the right. They have invested a lot of creative energy in building a whole universe of characters for that audience. But the Yellowstone cinematic universe, comprised of the show and its spinoffs 1883, 1923, and 6666, keeps getting snubbed by the Emmys in spite of its popularity and star power. David Simon. Joking about the flyover states; we sit there and talk about diversity, but were going to lump people in an entire region together and sit there and attack them and assign beliefs to them in counties where the average income is $33,000 and were going to align them with the top one percent, Sheridan said. CNSNews.com talked to Sheridan last July, when this profilefirst ran. This year's Oscars field is out, and its one of the strongest -- and most diverse -- that we've seen in years. Audiences dont care for awards or critics. By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email correspondence from us. Greetings From the Vortex of Unpredictability, was persistently at pains to distinguish authority from authoritarianism. Is 'Daisy Jones & The Six' Based on a True Story? gray-haired, paranoid character that we mock on social media, and more liberal media, and prestige media, purchased for more than $300 million this year, Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. I think our politicians have capitalized on that as well. If you hadn't actually watched any of Taylor Sheridan's series (Yellowstone, 1883, 1923, Tulsa King), you'd probably be left with the impression that he promotes a conservative viewpoint. Lets now look at his power, politics and potential progress. It confers political power and wealth and a sense of identity. This article contains spoilers for 1923 and the YELLOWSTONE universe at large.. Taylor Sheridan is undoubtedly one of the most talented creative voices to come out of television in the past decade . In the words of fellow Texan Mathew McConaughey, Sheridan is an aggressive centrist. Its not just anti-elite. Surprising nominations at the Golden Globes and the Producers' Guild Awards couldn't be converted into Oscar nominations, and we sadly won't see Ryan Reynolds in full Deadpool uniform goofing around on the red carpet. As these plot threads develop and tangle, the audiences rooting interests are quickly established: Viewers are persistently asked to cheer for the characters who understand, as Arendt argued, that there is a certain kind of freedom to be found in obedience to a deserving authority. This week, Sam connects with New York Times columnist Tressie McMillan Cottom, who recently wrote about the shows identity, its secret liberal fans, and how its apolitical politics impacts our culture at large. Ted Donaldson, Young Actor in Father Knows Best and A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, Dies at 89, Outer Banks Creators on Season 3s Deaths, Balancing Love Triangles and Whats Next, Travis Kelce Destroys the Studio as Indiana Jones in Saturday Night Live Promo, Outer Banks Star Reflects on Saying Goodbye to Show With Poetic Final Episode, Jefferson White, Adeline Rudolph Join Hellboy Movie 'The Crooked Man', Chris Pine Reveals What Really Happened With "Spit-Gate" and Explains Those 'Don't Worry Darling' Memes, Rachael Ray Daytime Talk Show to End After 17 Seasons, Shows and Podcasts Breaking Down the Murdaugh Family, Murder Investigation and Trial, Jon Stewart Brutally Confronts Republican Lawmaker Over Gun Deaths, Daisy Jones & the Six Showrunner on Song Switches, Fake/Real Concerts and Shutting Down the Sunset Strip, Rain Dogs Review: HBOs British Dramedy Offers Rewards for Those Who Brave the Bleakness, Vanessa Hudgens, Lilly Singh and Ashley Graham to Host Official Oscars Preshow, Star Hairstylist Jen Atkin Reveals Must-Have Hair Tools, Tutorials and Pro Tips In New MasterClass, Rihannas Puma x Fenty Is Coming Back Heres Where You Can Still Buy Those Cult-Fave Creepers, The Best Bridesmaid Dresses for Every Budget, From Under-$100 Gowns to Hollywood-Inspired Classics, BTS Army: Heres When and Where Legos Dynamite-Inspired Set Arrives Online and In Stores, The Big Lebowski Turns 25: People Didnt Get It, Jeff Bridges Recalls, How the Landscape of Native-Led Stories Has Changed Between Avatars: Were Flexing Our Sovereignty, The Definitive Voice of Entertainment News. While Yellowstone received mixed to negative reviews in its first season, it has since improved over the years and became especially popular among conservative American audiences. That's not to say Sheridan wouldn't want his terrific actors to get some recognition. Sheridan believes hes being overlooked by the awards and critics because he breaks storytelling rules. "For me as a storyteller, which is a great responsibility to an audience, you know someone is going to give you their time and their money to be entertained and possibly enlightened in some way, for me to try and impart my politics on them is, I think, arrogant and patronizing," Sheridan told CNSNews in a recent interview. And it showed its a man whos just incapableof expressing his feelings and saying how much he cares about somebody he cant do it. Instead of hats, guns, and horses, it would be headdresses, arrows, and horses. (Yellowstone star Kevin Costner got considerable pushback online for, of all things, wearing a T-shirt that supported Liz Cheney.) If it sounds odd to assert that a show I see as left-leaning should be interpreted as a paean to authority, that is because our conception of what authority actually means has been almost entirely eroded in modern life. Its shot beautifully. It is so interesting to see the response to your piece and to the show itself feel so polarized because, as you argue, its not that cut and dried. All Rights Reserved. Consider this one an expected snub. For lefties like myself, freedom primarily means freedom from things like intolerance, bigotry, economic inequality, and reproductive coercion. He has to convey all that regret, because its not resolved. Sheridan could, however, go a step further: He could make a series specifically about Indigenous people. But when a journalist got too close to uncovering his politics for a recent profile, he got pushback from Sheridan himself and the larger Paramount apparatus. He could make a show about another dark and unexplored chapter in American history: The forcible removal or ethnic cleansing of about 60,000 Native Americans. But the story is tailor-made for Sheridan. And they take a lot of pride in being outsiders in the mainstream Hollywood system. Taylor Sheridan's contemporary western masterpiece starring Kevin Costner is a deep dive into the Dutton family's efforts to save their ranch and way of life from the mighty forces of big business and even bigger government. Taylor Sheridan: 'The big joke on reservations is the white guy that shows up and says: "My grandma is Cherokee"' Gwilym Mumford The Sicario and Hell or High Water writer has turned director. Indeed, Sheridans shows all reflect the conviction that the conception of freedom endemic to modern American society is dogshitthat true freedom comes not through the absence of constraint, but the presence of authority. YOU'VE REACHED YOUR MONTHLY ARTICLE LIMIT. This yearslong debate exploded again last week after a critic at IndieWire declared that the newest Yellowstone spinoff, 1923 (the second of two, after the miniseries 1883), is not simply progressiveits unflinching look at the Indigenous boarding school system is critical race theory embodied. Sheridan's new film isHell or High Water. It opens August 12 andstarsJeff Bridges, Chris Pine and Ben Foster, and tells a story of Texas brothers Toby (Pine) and Tanner (Foster)who rob banksto save the family farm. Categories Pitching & Selling, Script Perfection, The Screenwriter's Life Tags 101studios, cowboys, montana, texas, tvseries, yellowstone. The Merc's run ends here. In Varietys Top 100 telecasts for 2021, Yellowstone features as the only cable show on the list. Taylor Sheridan is dismissing the notion that his series Yellowstone falls into easy political categorization. Of course, another explanation for the snubs may be Sheridans decision to physically distance himself from the screen production hubs. Thats a red-state show?". But what these characters almost never are is confused, and therein lies the appeal of Sheridans shows. I love watching Clooneys work, but what has it achieved? At one point one of the brothers says, The concealed carry law makes in damned hard to rob a bank.. I wanted to explore if Sheridan is the most important and influential screenwriter today. Yellowstone creator Taylor Sheridan responds to the show being called a "red-state" show. That doesnt justify what they do, but it does explain. In a column reacting to the lack of Emmy nominations for the show, The Hollywood Reporter chief television critic Daniel Fienberg said there was no truth to any assumption that TV Academy voters are too woke to appreciate the series. Yet, for my money, what is most interesting about this interpretive fracas is not which political reading of Sheridans seriesconservative or progressiveis correct. 1998-2023, Media Research Center. And they are offered up as being at least as complex as the Duttons. They are pursued by Marcus (Jeff Bridges), a Texas Ranger with only a few months away fromretirement. While it is a bank that gives the brothers the predatory loan, Sheridan says that the brothers "had to take action and work at it" to get the loan and could have turned it down. SURPRISE: Ruth Negga nominated for "Loving". And while I enjoyed Dont Look Up as a piece of entertainment, we all know the amount of change it will bring: exactly nothing. Hell make sure his stories are palatable for the audience theyre about, and not just to the intellectual elite. He tells CNSNews: The reality of living in a really small town far from a big town, is that you dont have the support services that exist. the scapegoating; abuse, torment and hypocrisy shown by the likes of Beth, John, even Rip; etc. In fact, it has some media elites working in and on this show. The weird politics of television's most successful producer. Although the American left and right differ profoundly on nearly every issue of importance, what both camps share is a conception of freedom that the philosopher Isaiah Berlin famously called negative liberty. For Berlin, a society that values negative liberty understands freedom as the absence ofconstraints on ones behavior. When has Sorkin ever portrayed ordinary people? Your Aunt Betty is like my Aunt Helen or my grandma or all of the other people that I grew up watching stories with. For viewers like Douthat, the Yellowstone universe is one big traditionalist romance, offering the ranchs masculine freedom as an alternative to the crowded suffocations of the city.. If it sounds romantic, it is not naive. Terms of Service apply. Taylor Sheridan (born May 21, 1970) [1] [2] is an American filmmaker and actor. With names such as Clark Johnson (The Wire, now also Mayor of Kingstown), Terence Winter (Boardwalk Empire, now Kansas City) and Tom Hanks leaking into the Sheridan universe, my guess is that the detractor pundits will soon capitulate. But this isnt the end! The "Hidden Figures" star may have gotten a Golden Globes nomination, but she fell short with the Academy. All rights reserved. On top of that, that Yellowstone's fanbase skews more towards the right in terms of politics has given the series a particular reputation among those less familiar with the plot and characters. In anticipation of his magnum opus nomination at this years SAG Awards, Sheridan balked at the tendency of many Yellowstone viewers to over-analyse plot, character dynamics and arcsWhile certainly no celebrity/dignitary, I cant help but wonder if he was taking a swipe at an avid consumer like me, who is turned off by the glorification of forceful, vulgar-mouthed women like Beth, who (mind you) is privileged and not impervious to luxury and superficial indulgence, DONT GET ME WRONG have thoroughly enjoyed the show, but wholly unimpressed by EVERYONES treatment of Jamie, i.e. Given that "Yellowstone" is technically in competition with the enduringly popular "Sunday Night Football . The argument thatYellowstoneand shows of its ilk are discriminated against because of ideology is based on this peculiar insinuation that Taylor Sheridan and George Will are coffee-drinking companions, he wrote. Should he put this to good use, he may be in a unique position to help change the politics of a troubled people, and contribute to some badly needed progress. While he didn't manage to get a Golden Globes nomination, the Academy took note of Hedges' performance. Subscribe to the podcast here. These are not exactly popular Republican talking points. This show in post-Trump America, the political backdrop of white grievance and white reclamation that we are undergoing, trying to claw back to a sort of mythical 40, 50 years ago, when our. This was the base of the Democratic party for 100 years. When Sheridan who once called Donald Trump that motherf**ker was accused of making television for Republicans, he responded incredulously. In this universe, the central characters (Kayce in Yellowstone, Mike in Mayor Of Kingstown, Brennan andThe Duttons in 1883) model dignified and moral actions, offering an alternative to the cynicism and hatred in many of the critically acclaimed shows full of rich a-holes. Theres been some debate this week about what exactly those are. WARNING: spoilers for 1883 and Yellowstone. SNUB: Annette Bening for "20th Century Women". If TV shows could vote,Yellowstoneand Emmy favorite (and, according to Netflix, massive hit)Ozarkwould probably support the same candidates.. And the Thoroughbred Sheridan seems to be, there is a lot of mileage left. In Hell or High water the Texas Ranger Marcus, played by Jeff Bridges, is facing retirement. ), Sheridan was more open to discussing this remark saying that he meant that you should be mindful of not berating the subject you are trying to educate and find a way for them to digest your point of view without turning them off to it., Also Read: Yellowstone Spin-Off 1923 Gets December Premiere Date. Try finding that in the world of Logan Roy. I agree with TheWrap's Terms of Service and Privacy Policy and provide my consent to receive marketing communications from them. He includes women and minorities in his features, but only to exploit them or mistreat them. ', The prolific television producer continued, The shows talking about the displacement of Native Americans and the way Native American women were treated and about corporate greed and the gentrification of the West, and land-grabbing. Well, thats a low bar.And hes definitely spending more money on his shows than I think Tyler is spending. by Rick Marin. In an interview in November 2022 that touched on accusations that Yellowstone and its spinoffs are aimed at Republicans, Sheridan responded incredulously. Youve got Black cowboys. You wont do it. (Pappu posits that its this remark that is key to decoding Sheridans innate popularity. Maybe Sheridans obsession with plains and horses can operate as a Trojan horse to educate people otherwise unwilling to listen. Get the latest episodes Thursdays. But the cowboy hats and horses may also obscure Sheridans real politics. Published Nov 13, 2022 Yellowstone creator Taylor Sheridan responds to the show being labeled as conservative, explaining that the series includes progressive themes. You\'ll receive the next newsletter in your inbox. The Wagner opera returns to the Met for the first time in 17 years. Right now, it already serves up western-style EXT-DAY shots, but I could see soundstages added to the mix as Jackson did with Stone Street Studios. For conservatives, the real heroes of this prequel can be Jacob Dutton (Harrison Ford)the unkillable patriarchand the prodigal son Spencer (Brandon Sklenar), a lion-hunter and veteran of WWI who is (literally) the shows great white hope, as his promise to come to the familys rescue hangs over the entire first season. With its impressive ratings, Yellowstone was considered to be among the most surprising 2022 Emmys snubs when it failed to land a single nomination. Like Teonna, both men are faced with endless physical hardships, but they are spared the hardship of uncertainty, indecision, or insecurity about their identity. He quit his job acting in shows such as Sons of Anarchy and sought to tell his own stories, including the screenplay for Denis Villeneuves Sicario. But he had no idea of the political climate that would be on the horizon. The publication cites New York Times columnist Ross Douthat having referred to the Kevin Costner-fronted series as the most red-state show on television, along with Daily Mail having suggested that Yellowstone is too anti-woke to win awards. Exactly. Yeah.Now, I think Taylor Sheridan has better wigs on his sets hands down. Weak box office numbers and late screening releases hampered the film's campaign, and it will have to settle for just a Best Cinematography nomination. Its self-reliance. Taylor Sheridan is an American actor, screenwriter and director. All these things, when you study them, start to explain the political leanings that have nothing to do with ideology. Its a brutal, horrific chapter in American history that like the 1921 Tulsa Race Massacre depicted in Damon Lindelofs Watchmen is something that most Americans werent knowledgeable about. Please unpack this for me.Theyve both identified an audience that feels isolated and rejected by mainstream popular culture. Hell or High Water aims to bring those affected by poverty and those in power together. Karel speaks more European languages than you have fingers on your left hand, which he is still trying to find a use for in his hometown of Sydney, Australia. Sign up for our MRCTV Daily newsletter to receive the latest news. Emerald was one of Cleopatra's favorite gems. Yellowstone creator Taylor Sheridan responds to the show being called a " red-state " show. He said his surgery was a success, but he needs time to heal before he can tour again. But poverty is poverty, Sheridan added. By Joe Leydon December 13, 2020 Taylor Sheridan is on the phone, on the road. Subscribe for full access to The Hollywood Reporter, The prolific producer said he laughs when he hears his hit Paramount Network series referred to as "the conservative show.". Never. Hannah Arendt, the German philosopher whose work on totalitarianism had a renaissance during the Trump era, was persistently at pains to distinguish authority from authoritarianism. 2023 The Hollywood Reporter, LLC. This email will be used to sign into all New York sites. For many years, his life's ambition was simply to become sheriff of Cranfills Gap . It is a white grievance that you can feel good about. Audiences are sick and tired of being lectured to. Of course, it doesnt matter anyway, because these little statuettes are all about perception. Even better, it has the ability to draw viewers in from across the country's fragmented political landscape. After the wedding must be delayed so the Dutton men can attend to a herd of cattle imperiled by drought, Cara counsels the distraught Elizabeth: Youll miss more than weddings for cattle, my dear. In an interview with The Atlantic, Sheridan explains that while Yellowstone has a predominantly white cast and is set in the Republican majority state of Montana, the themes and premises explored in the plot lines of the series are rooted in progressive ideals. (Yellowstone star Kevin Costner got considerable pushback online for, of all things, wearing a T-shirt that supported Liz Cheney.) This password will be used to sign into all, host of Into It, the flagship culture podcast from Vulture, Photo-Illustration: Vulture; Photo by Paramount Network, Bad Projection Is Ruining the Movie Theater Experience, 6 Stand-ups Analyze ChatGPTs Attempts to Steal Their Jobs, How to Watch and Stream Every 2023 Oscar-Nominated Movie, Travis Barkers Finger Is Now the Enema of Blink-182 Fans. All of these people are getting good lighting and good costume design. The feel-good drama about a group of African-American female NASA scientists topped the box office for two consecutive weeks and has now piloted itself to a Best Picture nomination. But always with the assumption that you will aspire to be like us.. Its the reason why Sheridan balks at how comedians and pundits like Bill Maher present their politics. "It just seems that when youre dealing with money, the consequences of working with the wrong person are greater. And you would be hard-pressed to say any of them arent free in the ways that matter. He has trained students worldwide, and worked with half a dozen Academy Award nominees. Did you hear my jaw on the floor right now? David Glasser, the CEO of Sheridans 101 Studios, was upset. So were Paramount publicists and various studio executives. and their child is expected to inherit Yellowstone, The 'Riverdale' Final Season Trailer Looks Deranged in All the Best/Worst Ways. All Rights Reserved. Perhaps not unrelatedly, Yellowstone has gained a reputation, including in this very publication, as a conservative series, one targeted toward viewers who also voted for a certain former president. We just live in these two extremes. Why would a filmmaker buy a horse and cattle ranch covering an area twice the size of Chicago, at a cost of around $350m? The show itself is likely to continue beyond season 5 and has already spawned three prequel shows, 1883 and the upcoming 1923 and 6666. Perhaps critics like me miss the entire point when we spend our energy trying to crack the code of the Yellowstone universes politics. Oscar Nominee Taylor Sheridan on Guns, Politics in Film and 'Hell or High Water'. Pappu brought up a 2017 interview when Sheridan was promoting his film Wind River and wondered how President Trump hadnt been impeached yet (Can we just impeach that motherfer right now?). There were countless choices before the film started, in their imagined past, that they didnt make, that could have altered the course of where they ended up. But their audiences are so loyal and bring out the same sort of shame and embarrassment among people who feel like they shouldnt be watching it.